Congratulations to the following players for making the EDFL Team of the Year:
| Year / Season | Grade | Players / Coaches |
| 2002 | A & B | Nick Chalmers, Clayton Hatch, Chris Robertson, Matt McCartney |
| 2003 | A | Darin Milner, Nick Chalmers, Drew Fletcher |
| 2004 | A | Clayton Hatch, Nick Chalmers, Blake Albones, Chris Robertson |
| 2005 | A | Chris Robertson |
| 2008 | A | Frank Raso, Wayne Foster |
| 2009 | B | Steve Vernon, Alex Gleeson, Jack Pascu, Ray Harrison, Frank Raso, Tom White, Todd Clark (Coach) |
| 2010 | A | Alex Gleeson, Jack Pascu |
| 2011 | A | Alex Gleeson, Sam Higgs, Jack Pascu, Joel McDonald, Phil Plunkett (Coach) |
| 2012 | A | Tom German |
| 2014 | B | Tom German, Jack Pascu |
| 2015 | B | Rhys Bloomfield, Tom German |
| 2017 | B | Michael Hooper, Jack Pascu |
| 2018 | B | Kirk Lang |
| 2021 | A | Mikayla Barnes, Iesha Atik, Gloria Elarmaly, Olivia Storer |
| 2021 | C | Daniel Rajab (C), Liam Molloy, Ryan Smith, Blair Cronin, Zac Taylor |
| 2022 | A | Samantha German, Maggie Styles |
| 2022 | C | Ryan Smith, Jedd Taylor, Liam Molloy, Daniel Rajab, Brad Cox, Blair Cronin |
| 2023 | A | Samantha German, Emily Findlay, Alexandra Quigley, Mia Briedis, Shanel Camilleri |
| 2023 | C | Max Gleeson, Hirsi Twomey, Jedd Taylor, Daniel Rajab, Blair Cronin, Mitch Leathers |