Congratulations to the following who have kicked 9 or more goals in a game for Oak Park:
| Goals | Year | Player | Grade | Opposition |
| 18 | 2011 | John Bassi | A Res | Doutta Stars |
| 16 | 2002 | Blake Albones | A | Avondale Heights |
| 16 | 1983 | Ted Casson | B | Brunswick City |
| 15 | 1962 | Daryl Sheppard | U15 1 | West Essendon Youth Club |
| 15 | 2005 | Nathan Valladares | U18 1 | Moonee Valley |
| 14 | 1977 | Trevor Milledge | B Res | Essendon Youth Centre |
| 14 | 2004 | Bryce Crosswell | U16 2 | Hadfield |
| 14 | 2006 | John Bassi | U18 1 | Keilor Park |
| 13 | 1961 | Anatole Horoch | U15 | Param B |
| 13 | 1982 | Ted Casson | B | Coburg Districts |
| 13 | 1982 | Shane O’Brien | U18 1 | Westmeadows |
| 13 | 1982 | Craig German | B Res | Essendon Youth Centre |
| 13 | 1984 | Graham Matson | A3 | Tullamarine |
| 13 | 1993 | Ricky Stamos | A Res | Avondale Heights |
| 13 | 1994 | Rob Smith | A Res | Avondale Heights |
| 13 | 2003 | Jack Pascu | U16 2 | Hadfield |
| 12 | 1967 | Werner Martin | U15 2 | Moonee Valley |
| 12 | 1980 | Ted Casson | B | East Brunswick |
| 12 | 1993 | Michael Cookman | U18 1 | Airport West |
| 12 | 2004 | Shane Sheppard | A | Moonee Valley |
| 12 | 2009 | Steve Shaw | B Res | Roxburgh Park |
| 12 | 2023 | Ray Harrison | C Res | Hadfield |
| 11 | 1968 | Stan Mitchell | U17 1 | Airport West |
| 11 | 1981 | Peter German | U18 1 | East Keilor |
| 11 | 1982 | Daryn McKenzie | B Res | Moonee Valley |
| 11 | 1983 | Brian Drew | B Res | Essendon Youth Centre |
| 11 | 1983 | Darren Scott | B Res | St Olivers |
| 11 | 1984 | Ross Ewert | A3 | Tullamarine |
| 11 | 1994 | Brendan Cornell | A | Keilor Park |
| 11 | 1996 | Andrew Bouzikas | U16 1 | North Coburg Saints |
| 11 | 2001 | Blake Albones | A | Aberfeldie |
| 11 | 2002 | Matt McCartney | A | Keilor Park |
| 11 | 2004 | Tom German | U14 2 | Maribyrnong Park |
| 11 | 2007 | Michael Peart | U18 1 | Keilor Park |
| 11 | 2009 | Giles Williams | B | Airport West |
| 11 | 2011 | Michael Roach | U15 5 | Roxburgh Park |
| 11 | 2013 | Liam Molloy | U16 3 | Tullamarine |
| 11 | 2013 | Kane O’Halloran | U14 3 | Burnside Heights |
| 11 | 2022 | Blair Cronin | C | Jacana |
| 11 | 2022 | Ray Harrison | C Res | Burnside Heights |
| 11 | 2023 | Ray Harrison | C Res | Hadfield |
| 10 | 1967 | Geoff Leopold | U13 1 | Ascot Youth Centre |
| 10 | 1981 | Tim Whelan | U18 1 | East Keilor |
| 10 | 1983 | Brian Drew | B Res | East Keilor |
| 10 | 1989 | Shane O’Brien | A | Pascoe Vale |
| 10 | 1992 | Shane O’Brien | A | Avondale Heights |
| 10 | 1994 | Brendan Cornell | A | Moonee Valley |
| 10 | 1996 | Shane Sheppard | U14 B | Glenroy |
| 10 | 2009 | Ray Harrison | B | Sydenham Hillside |
| 10 | 2011 | Mitchell Leathers | U14 2 | Craigieburn |
| 10 | 2013 | Kane O’Halloran | U14 3 | East Sunbury |
| 10 | 2016 | Liam Stacey-Bradford | U18 2 | Aberfeldie 2 |
| 10 | 2022 | Ray Harrison | C Res | Burnside Heights |
| 10 | 2022 | Ray Harrison | C Res | Hadfield |
| 9 | 1964 | Barry Gladman | B | Riverside Stars |
| 9 | 1966 | Garry Whelan | A | Doutta Stars |
| 9 | 1966 | Norm Bellman | C | Essendon High School |
| 9 | 1968 | Jim Neil | U13 B | Essendon Baptist St Johns |
| 9 | 1969 | Geoff Leopold | U15 1 | Ascot Vale |
| 9 | 1970 | Ollie Gulbis | U11 A | Tullamarine |
| 9 | 1971 | Doug Marshall | A Res | Glenroy |
| 9 | 1982 | Ted Casson | B | Essendon Youth Centre |
| 9 | 1982 | Trevor German | B Res | Westmeadows |
| 9 | 1982 | Brett Scott | B Res | East Keilor |
| 9 | 1984 | Craig German | A | Hadfield |
| 9 | 1986 | Wayne Randall | A | Airport West |
| 9 | 1992 | Gary Ransome | A | Keilor Park |
| 9 | 1996 | Victor Chiodo | U16 1 | Keilor Park |
| 9 | 2000 | Blake Albones | A | Strathmore |
| 9 | 2001 | Blake Albones | A | Strathmore |
| 9 | 2001 | Anthony Vugdelija | U18 1 | Airport West |
| 9 | 2001 | Matthew Sciberras | U18 1 | Airport West |
| 9 | 2002 | Blake Albones | A | Moonee Valley |
| 9 | 2004 | Jake Melksham | U14 2 | Maribyrnong Park |
| 9 | 2004 | Nick Zakhour | U16 2 | Hadfield |
| 9 | 2007 | Wayne Foster | A Res | Doutta Stars |
| 9 | 2008 | Nathan Sciberras | U18 1 | Maribyrnong Park |
| 9 | 2010 | Andrew Nader | U18 1 | Doutta Stars |
| 9 | 2011 | Brayden Field | U16 2 | Roxburgh Park |
| 9 | 2011 | Mitchell Leathers | U14 2 | Airport West |
| 9 | 2013 | Chris Drew | U16 3 | Tullamarine |
| 9 | 2013 | Kane O’Halloran | U14 3 | Tullamarine |
| 9 | 2015 | Liam Molloy | U18 D1 | Craigieburn |
| 9 | 2015 | Liam Molloy | U18 D1 | East Keilor |
| 9 | 2015 | Kane O’Halloran | U16 2 | Maribyrnong Park |
| 9 | 2015 | Kane O’Halloran | U16 2 | Keilor 2 |
| 9 | 2015 | Nathan Strkalj | U16 4 | Burnside Heights 2 |
| 9 | 2016 | Dean Clare | B | Westmeadows |
| 9 | 2021 | Jedd Tayor | C | Jacana |
| 9 | 2022 | Mitchell Leathers | C | Jacana |
| 9 | 2023 | Ray Harrison | C Res | East Sunbury |